DOSMUKHAMEDOV: Repealing SOGI is easy — governing what comes next is harder

DOSMUKHAMEDOV: Repealing SOGI is easy — governing what comes next is harder
Source: Unsplash / @katierainbow
| Sitka Media Guest Columnist
Your voice is worth sharing. Write for us.

The BC Conservatives won a majority on October 24 after promising to repeal SOGI 123 in favour of introducing a new anti-bullying program and strengthening parental notification and opt-out rights.

But an electoral mandate is not an educational policy. The test for Premier-designate Lorne Doerkson is whether his government can replace a controversial framework with something demonstrably better.

Doerkson called SOGI "an absolute lightning rod for division in our province."

Removing its name will not resolve that division. The government must first answer a practical question: what exactly will it repeal, and what will take its place?

Introduced in 2016, SOGI 123 provides optional educational resources intended to promote safer schools. Separately, provincial requirements oblige school districts and independent schools to address sexual orientation and gender identity in their anti-bullying policies. The resources are optional; the obligations are not. British Columbia’s Human Rights Code also protects against discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity or expression.

The framework’s future was already uncertain. Provincial funding for ARC Foundation declined from $350,000 annually to $200,000 in 2025–26, with no allocation for 2026–27. In September, ARC announced plans to wind down and explore transferring SOGI 123 to another organization.

So what will the Conservatives repeal: teaching resources, provincial guidance, district policies or anti-bullying requirements themselves? These decisions have different legal and educational consequences. Repealing a name is not the same as reforming a system.

But the controversy reaches beyond one educational resource. It concerns the relationship between the family, the school and the state in shaping the next generation.

The family is a foundational institution of society. Through families, children inherit language, culture, religion, heritage and moral traditions. These connections sustain democratic diversity. Schools have an indispensable educational role, but cannot replace families in transmitting identity across generations.

Childhood and adolescence are formative periods for personality, judgment and individual identity. Educational policies touching these matters demand particular care. Schools should encourage intellectual exploration and independent thinking, not ideological conformity. Learning to encounter different beliefs is part of education; being compelled to adopt them is not.

Canada’s residential-school history warns against institutions overriding family and cultural continuity. While that history is certainly not comparable to SOGI 123, its enduring lesson is that governments must approach interventions affecting children’s upbringing and identity with humility and restraint.

This matters in British Columbia, with its diverse religious, cultural, and philosophical communities. Schools should be places of cooperation, not battlegrounds for competing political worldviews.

Protecting students from bullying because of sexual orientation or gender identity is a necessary public responsibility — but requiring respect for human dignity is not equivalent to compelling agreement with particular philosophical understandings of sexuality, gender or family life. Parental authority must likewise respect children’s developing autonomy and rights.

Evidence must inform the government’s response. A 2024 University of British Columbia evaluation, drawing on surveys of more than 98,000 students, reported reductions in some forms of bullying and sexual-orientation discrimination associated with SOGI 123. Those findings merit consideration, although observational evidence cannot establish that every teaching practice caused the improvements or is beyond scrutiny.

The responsible course is neither automatic retention nor immediate abolition. It is an independent, time-limited review before any replacement is finalized.

The review should involve child-development, education, mental-health and child-rights experts, alongside teachers, Indigenous educators and parents from diverse communities. It should examine materials actually used, assess age-appropriateness and educational outcomes, and publish recommendations on student safety and parental transparency.

Any replacement must meet three tests.

First, parents should have access to instructional materials, advance information about sensitive subjects and reasonable procedures for objections and legally appropriate opt-outs. Transparency must not become compulsory disclosure of a student’s private identity. Saskatchewan’s 2023 use of the notwithstanding clause to shield its parental-consent law illustrates the constitutional difficulties of conflating those questions.

Second, every student must retain effective protection against bullying and discrimination, including identity-based harassment, confidential reporting and timely intervention.

Third, independent evaluation and clear transitional guidance must precede withdrawal of existing resources. Once the government repeals SOGI 123, responsibility for the effectiveness of its replacement will belong to the Conservatives.

Neither the state nor the family possesses unlimited authority over a child’s developing identity. Parents have substantial responsibilities, schools have public educational duties, and children possess rights of their own. Responsible government must reconcile these principles.

Conservatism is not the reflexive dismantling of everything inherited from a previous administration. Nor should any government use education to impose a preferred worldview on families.

Repeal may fulfil a campaign promise. Only a credible replacement that protects every child, respects families, safeguards cultural and religious diversity, and rests on sound developmental and educational evidence will fulfil the responsibilities of government.

Dr. Yerzhan Dosmukhamedov, DPhil (Oxon), is an independent policy analyst based in Vancouver, a former senior diplomat and a former Senior Associate Member at St Antony’s College, University of Oxford.

ENJOYED THIS STORY?

Join the Inner Circle and get Sitka Media's best BC journalism straight to your inbox.

Discussion

More to Explore