Ottawa's proposal to provide tax relief on up to $45,000 in annual income from creative work is raising questions about whether musicians who rely on teaching and other jobs to make ends meet will fully benefit.
Jordanne Erichsen, a former opera singer, vocal coach, and founder of EXPRESS Voice Studio, says the proposal is welcome news for Canadian artists, but the government needs to consider how musicians actually earn a living.
“My initial reaction was that's fantastic. That's absolutely fantastic,” Erichsen told Sitka Media. “But immediately after is the question of what counts as artistic work.”
For many musicians, earning a living involves juggling performances, recording sessions, teaching, and sometimes jobs entirely unrelated to music.
Erichsen says teaching is particularly important because performance opportunities are often short-term contracts, leaving musicians with gaps in their income.
“So in this way, I think teaching is a core part of being an artist in Canada,” she said.
But it's unclear whether income from teaching would qualify under Ottawa's proposed tax credit.
Erichsen worries that artists who are still establishing their careers could see fewer benefits if the government limits eligibility to income earned directly from performances or other creative work.
She pointed to opera singers as an example of the financial pressures artists face, noting that a single audition can cost between $500 and $3,000 when travel, coaching, and accompanist expenses are factored in.
For emerging artists who earn only a portion of their income through creative work, she argues that a tax credit limited to those earnings may provide little relief.
Instead, Erichsen wants Ottawa to consider making the first $45,000 earned by qualifying artists tax-free, regardless of whether the income comes from artistic work.
“It shouldn't just be $45,000 on what you can prove is your artistic revenue,” she said.
She suggests the government could establish criteria for determining who qualifies as an artist, potentially based on the number of performances they complete or the hours they dedicate to their craft.
Erichsen says the goal should be to support artists throughout their careers, particularly those who are just starting out and may not yet earn enough from their creative work to support themselves.
“If we really want to help artists, we have to understand the life cycle of being an artist and where they need the most help, which is at the beginning of their career when they're trying to get to a point where they're making money from their art,” she said.
The federal government's 2026 budget introduced plans for a new Canada Creative Credit, which would provide tax relief on up to $45,000 in annual qualifying net business income from original creative work when combined with the existing basic personal amount.
In a statement to Sitka Media, a Department of Finance official said the government intends to consult Canadians and the cultural sector on the proposed credit, which is expected to take the form of a non-refundable personal income tax credit.
The official said the measure could support artists by encouraging creativity, artistic production, and cultural entrepreneurship in Canada.
Further details are expected to be announced in the spring 2027 economic update.
